Hospitals Enable Predators Like Robert Hadden via Loophole

New York Legal Loophole Allows Hospitals to Protect Predators Like Robert Hadden

Laws in the State of New York have been put into place with the aim of protecting patients from the misconduct and sexual abuse of doctors, physicians and other medical personnel.

Unfortunately, many of these laws are not enforced (or enforceable) to the length at which patient safety and moral accountability requires them to be.

The institutions that employ abusers become wholly implicated and responsible for the abuse that has occurred on their premises when laws on patient safety are disregarded, reports on misconduct are squashed, and doctors who abuse patients are allowed to continue their practice.

This phenomenon is visible in the Robert Hadden Sexual Abuse Case, in which Columbia University enabled Robert Hadden to sexually abuse numerous patients for decades, and failed to notify thousands of women exposed to the predator doctor when ordered to by the New York State Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC).

Columbia University refused to report sexual abuse committed by Hadden to authorities, and allowed him to keep seeing patients in private until his license was revoked.

Columbia has evaded responsibility for their role in Hadden’s sex crimes through legal loopholes that make it difficult for authorities to force their hand in notifying patients of the abuse that has occurred.

Table of Contents

New York State Laws to Prevent Physician Misconduct and How Columbia University Failed its Patients

Laws and statutes in New York State pertaining to “Professional Medical Conduct” require medical institutions to reprimand employees that commit abuse, including the stripping of medical licenses, loss of employment, and reports to authorities.

New York State Law also requires medical institutions that have employed abusers to send notice to former patients about the misconduct that has occurred.

The notification of patients is required by the New York State Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC).

When Robert Hadden was convicted of sexually abusing six patients in 2016, the New York State Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC) ordered Columbia to notify all patients that Hadden was stripped of his license.

To this day, Columbia University has not notified the 6-8,000 women who were exposed to Hadden that he had his license revoked due to repeated sexual assaults on patients. 

Columbia University Has Failed to Notify Patients About Predator OBGYN Robert Hadden

In 2013, Columbia University sent out letters to women on Hadden’s patient list.

The letter indicated that Hadden was closing his practice and offered women the opportunity to continue care with another “trusted” OBGYN at their facilities.

Unbeknownst to patients, Hadden was under active criminal investigation for licking a patient as the letter was sent out.

One week after the letter was released, Hadden was indicted for the felony assault of multiple patients.

He was then convicted in 2016.

Even though Columbia has all patient information and the proven ability to send out letters or notifications en masse, the University contends that it is Hadden’s responsibility to notify patients of his de-licensing and charges, and not theirs.

Columbia interprets the NYS OPMC order to say that it is Hadden’s responsibility to notify his patients of the stripping of his license and closing of his practice despite having access to extensive patient lists and records.

Mandated Reporters – Another Legal Loophole Used by Columbia University to Evade Responsibilities

In New York State, it is mandatory for certain employees of institutions like hospitals and churches to report all instances of staff misconduct or inappropriate behavior, or in other instances where it is suspected that abuse or mistreatment has occurred.

This rule is enforced by New York Social Services Law § 491.

Mandated reporters include, but are not limited to, the following occupations and positions:

  • Physicians
  • Registered Physician’s Assistants
  • Registered Nurses
  • Surgeons
  • Medical Examiners
  • Psychologists
  • Social Services Workers

Too often, institutions ignore the rules on mandated reporting in order to protect staff from repercussions, uphold their institutional culture, or to save themselves from backlash, scrutiny, or civil action.

In the case of serial sexual abuse committed by Robert Hadden at Columbia University medical facilities, Columbia’s medical personnel were mandated to report all forms of misconduct and suspected misconduct to state agencies.

However, there are no “teeth” to the law that requires this reporting.

Columbia University medical personnel and higher-ups knew about Hadden’s serial sexual abuse for decades, but have faced no consequences for their failure in reporting misconduct to relevant state agencies.

Why Does Columbia University Refuse to Notify Hadden’s Victims?

Columbia University has refused to notify 6,000-8,000 women and girls who were exposed to Robert Hadden about the revocation of his medical license and the abuse he committed for decades.

Columbia was ordered by the NYS OPMC to notify patients of these issues.

Even though Columbia has all patient information—and the proven ability to send out letters to their patients—the university is claiming that “a loophole in the law” makes it Hadden’s responsibility to notify patients, not their responsibility.

From a former patient’s perspective, who may be completely unaware of Hadden’s history of abuse, they might believe that they are the only person who has been sexually abused by the predator OBGYN.

By sending out notice to all patients, it would make victims aware of the following: 

  1. They’re not alone and others have been abused in Columbia’s medical facilities by Robert Hadden.
  2. Columbia University allowed the sexual abuse to occur and enabled Robert Hadden to continue abusing patients for decades.
  3. Columbia University is liable for allowing the crimes of Robert Hadden to occur.

It is irresponsible and problematic that Columbia University expects Hadden, the serial sexual predator, to contact the women he abused and inform them of his de-licensing and criminal charges.

Columbia has access to patient records, the system in place and contact information to notify patients, and the power to do the right thing.

They will not contact former patients of Robert Hadden to protect the interests of their board of trustees and other Columbia University officials.

Robert Hadden: Criminally Charged for Sexually Assaulting Patients

Hadden has been convicted of felony sexual assault of a patient (oral contact) but has inexplicably been given a sentence that more closely resembles an early-paid retirement than the criminal sentence for a convicted sexual felon.

What’s even more shocking is that even though the NYPD arrested Hadden at a Columbia OBGYN clinic for making oral contact with a patient during a bogus medical exam, he was allowed to continue working unsupervised, where he continued to sexually exploit even more patients.

In 2016, Hadden pleaded guilty to two state charges of a criminal sex act in the third degree (felony conviction) and forcible touching.

Through a deal made with Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr., Hadden was offered a deal that included no prison time, and he was placed on the lowest tier of the sex offenders list.

After a letter by one of Columbia’s Chairmen was discovered, which shows that Hadden had a history of sexually abusing patients dating all the way back to 1993 – Hadden was indicted a second time and is now being Federally prosecuted.

Hadden is facing federal counts of “enticing and inducing individuals to travel interstate to engage in illegal sexual activity” and is awaiting trial.

The new criminal trial for Robert Hadden begins soon.

If found guilty, Hadden faces life in prison.

Contact Us Anonymously if You are a Survivor or Whistleblower of Robert Hadden's Sexual Abuse

For the past decade, our Founder Anthony T. DiPietro, Esq. has been suing Columbia University to hold them accountable for covering up decades of Robert Hadden’s sexual exploitation and abuse.

From the early years, Mr. DiPietro made a conscious and deliberate decision to put his clients’ level of comfort first.

While you have likely read the stories of several survivors who have gone public to hold Columbia accountable, there are also hundreds of other women, girls, and men, who Mr. DiPietro has represented that you haven’t read about.

The reasons for this are quite simple: 

  1. Mr. DiPietro understands the complex emotions and challenges that victims and survivors wrestle with when deciding to come forward. As a result, he has committed himself to doing everything possible in order to protect and support his clients throughout this process.
  2. The laws in New York State allow victims and survivors of sexual abuse to file their claims anonymously—thus protecting their identities and private lives while they’re seeking to hold Columbia and Hadden accountable.

If you or a loved one suffered sexual abuse by Robert Hadden, you are eligible to file a legal claim anonymously.

In addition, those who witnessed Hadden’s abuse are encouraged to share their stories or reports about what they’ve seen or heard.

If you decide to contact us regarding Hadden’s sexual abuse, confidentiality is guaranteed.

We understand the pain you’re going through, and our staff is sensitive to your needs as a victim or whistleblower.  

Mr. DiPietro’s track record on this case includes:

  • Recovering $236 Million against Columbia University and Robert Hadden;
  • Forcing Columbia University to enact policies to increase patient safety; and
  • Helping pass two different laws that provide new victims and survivors with a path to justice (including the Adult Survivors Act & the Gender Motivated Violence Act)

Frequently Asked Questions

The data says they do not.

The New York State Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC), a branch of the New York State Department of Health, “investigates complaints about physicians, physician assistants and specialist assistants and monitors practitioners who are subject to Orders of the State Board for Professional Medical Conduct.”

Despite a high volume of complaints, Robert Hadden managed to evade disciplinary action by the OPMC until his eventual license surrender.

A piece by Type Investigations highlights the criticism of the OPMC. Reporters spoke to former agency employees, reviewed hundreds of documents, and analyzed data on doctor disciplinary actions, finding the following: 

  • Of the 3,755 penalties the board issued for all complaints from 2007 to 2018, almost three-quarters were negotiated agreements without hearings.
  • Roughly half of OPMC’s sexual misconduct punishments from 2007 to 2018 began after a doctor licensed in New York but practicing elsewhere was disciplined by another state’s medical board.
  • About 4% of misconduct complaints ended in board actions between 2007 and 2018. In that period, the agency has punished 279 doctors for sexual misconduct, an average of 23 per year.

Type Investigations also reported that internal reforms to protect patients were hard to come by, with an unearthed 2009 memo from five investigators stating that the agency had a:

“… favorable bias toward physicians… [that] can lead to overlooking, minimizing or excusing physicians sexual misconduct and to a reluctance to impose appropriate discipline.”

A former investigator further said that:

“It’s all about the numbers… it wasn’t about the victims, it wasn’t about the patients. It was about closing cases.”

Resources for Sexual Exploitation & Abuse Survivors

We’re currently investigating this case and many other cases involving serial sexual predators.

As more information becomes available on our cases, we will share it on the The DiPietro Law Firm Twitter account (@atdipietro).

If you’re a survivor of sexual exploitation and abuse, please contact our Free Consultation Helpline for a 100% confidential and free consultation about your case at (212) 233-3600.

You’re not alone anymore.

Discussion & Real-time Updates

No feed found with the ID 5. Go to the All Feeds page and select an ID from an existing feed.

Do You
Have A Case?

Here, at The DiPietro Law Firm, we’re committed to helping victims of sexual abuse and assault find the justice they deserve.

All information discussed during our consultations always remains completely 100% confidential.

Would you like our help?

About Anthony T. DiPietro

Founder Anthony T. DiPietro, Esq. is a compassionate and skilled trial attorney who has completely dedicated the past 23 years of his career to litigating medical malpractice and sexual abuse cases against major corporate institutions including hospitals, medical clinics, schools, and other wrongdoers.

Mr. DiPietro has also obtained some of New York State’s highest verdicts and settlements, and has been selected to New York State Super Lawyers® each year, for the past 10 years in a row.

In 2022, Mr. DiPietro was selected as one of America’s Top 100 High-Stakes Litigators for the landmark cases he’s won on behalf of survivors of sexual exploitation and abuse.

Verdicts & Settlements
Recent Posts
Do You
Have A Case?

Here, at The DiPietro Law Firm, we’re committed to helping victims of sexual abuse and assault find the justice they deserve.

All information discussed during our consultations always remains completely 100% confidential.

Would you like our help?

Related Articles

Cases We're Currently Litigating

Years of Abuse:  1987 – 2016

Brief:  For nearly three decades, Robert Hadden sexually exploited and abused girls and women at Columbia University, under the guise of OB-GYN care.

Read More:  Robert Hadden and Columbia University Sexual Abuse Cases

Years of Abuse:  1961 – 1996

Brief:  22 predator teachers and administrators, over the course of 35 years.

Years of Abuse:  1960 – 1982

Free Consultation Helpline

If you have any questions about whether or not you have a case, or just want to obtain more information about what you’ve experienced – feel free to contact us through our secure website chat.

You can also contact us by calling us at (212) 233-3600 or toll free at (800) 215-1003.

All of our consultations are free and 100% confidential. Thank you.